Skip to main content

November 2024: Shedding "Man Up" Mentality - The Real Talk on Men, Emotions, and Mental Health


How many times have you been told to “Man up!” or “boys/men don’t cry”?

When we really think about these commonly used phrases and zoom out at the bigger picture, we see a real problem with using this type of language. The problem being a society where being a “man” is correlated with toughness, resilience, lacking of emotions, being un-phased by things, and an example of "strength". 

Because of this, a huge stigma has developed for men to inadvertently build walls around emotional expression and vulnerability and feeling as though they are unable to genuinely tap into that part of themselves. 

The truth is, men feel just as deeply as anyone else, but the societal expectation to remain tough and unshaken often silences those emotions.

But what’s the toll from this mentality?

The pressure to appear strong and unemotional has real consequences. Studies show that men are less likely than women to seek help for mental health challenges, even though they are equally susceptible to depression, anxiety, and stress. Tragically, men are also more likely to die by suicide, with societal stigma often playing a significant role in their silence.

The "man up" mindset reinforces the idea that showing vulnerability is weak or unmanly. This leads to:

  • Bottling Emotions: 
    • Suppressed feelings can result in explosive anger, irritability, or long-term emotional numbness.
  • Unhealthy Coping Mechanisms: 
    • Many men turn to alcohol, drugs, or overworking as a way to escape their feelings.
  • Strained Relationships: 
    • Emotional walls hinder meaningful connections with partners, friends, and family.
  • Physical Health Risks: 
    • The stress of keeping emotions hidden can increase the risk of heart disease and other health problems.

But just because this is a stigmatized narrative for men, doesn’t mean we can’t challenge this and enter into an era of embracing emotional expression and vulnerability, no matter who you are. Think about a movement that happened in the late 2000’s, where all of a sudden there was a trend in boys/men wearing pink and the slogan “real men wear pink”. How can we modernize this now to “real men/boys express their emotions”? 

Breaking free from the "man up" mentality means redefining what strength actually represents. Strength isn’t about ignoring your feelings; it’s about facing them head-on. Here are a few ways we can collectively challenge outdated notions of masculinity:

  • Normalize Vulnerability: 
    • Vulnerability is not a weakness; it’s a human strength. Men should feel encouraged to talk about their feelings without fear of judgment.
  • Create Safe Spaces: 
    • Friends, family, and communities can create environments where men feel comfortable opening up. Ask genuine questions like, “How are you really doing?” and be ready to listen.
  • Teach Emotional Literacy: 
    • Many men were never taught to identify or process their emotions. Providing tools for emotional awareness, such as the Emotions/Feelings wheel below, psychoeducational books/workbooks, and therapy, can be transformative.
  • Challenge Gender Norms: 
    • Speak out when you hear phrases like “Boys don’t cry.” Educate others on how these outdated beliefs harm everyone, not just men.
  • Promote Therapy as a Tool, Not a Crutch: 
    • Therapy isn’t about fixing something broken; it’s about growth. Let’s normalize the idea of men seeking therapy as a way to thrive, not just survive.
  • A Call to Action for Men and Allies: 
    • Shedding the "man up" mentality doesn’t mean abandoning strength—it means expanding its definition. True strength lies in authenticity, connection, and self-awareness.

For men: It’s okay to cry. It’s okay to feel overwhelmed. It’s okay to not have all the answers. Reaching out for help isn’t giving up; it’s stepping up for yourself and the people you care about.

For allies: Support the men in your life by encouraging them to express their emotions. Check in regularly and remind them that it’s okay to feel—and heal.

The world is slowly shifting its view of masculinity, but the work isn’t done. As we collectively challenge harmful stereotypes, we open the door for men to live fuller, healthier lives. It’s time to shed the "man up" mentality and embrace a new narrative: "Expressing emotions is a universal human right." Real men don’t suppress their emotions—they own them.

Remember: You don’t have to carry it all alone. Asking for help is one of the bravest things you can do. Let’s normalize that.

Take Care, Pioneers!

-TWU CAPS


Resource: Emotion-Sensation Wheel - used to identify emotions/body sensations




Interested in other When Life Feels Messy content? 
Podcast - https://spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/GmTJzrDjQAb
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@whenlifefeelsmessy...
Instagram - @twucaps and @twudalhou_caps


TWU CAPS Contact Information:
Denton Front Office - 940-898-3801

Crisis Line - 940-898-4357

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

September 2023: Suicide Survivors of Loss

Resources for Suicide Prevention https://988lifeline.org/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=onebox https://www.samhsa.gov/newsroom/suicide-prevention-month https://988lifeline.org/how-we-can-all-prevent-suicide/ https://www.nami.org/Get-Involved/Awareness-Events/Suicide-Prevention-Month https://www.dhs.gov/employee-resources/news/2023/09/06/september-suicide-prevention-and-awareness-month https://www.nimh.nih.gov/get-involved/digital-toolkit-for-suicide-prevention-month Resources for Loss Survivors of Suicide https://sprc.org/tools/resources-survivors-suicide-loss/ https://afsp.org/taking-care-of-yourself/ https://988lifeline.org/help-yourself/loss-survivors/ https://afsp.org/ive-lost-someone/ https://allianceofhope.org/ https://health.maryland.gov/bha/suicideprevention/Documents/What%20Survivors%20of%20Suicide%20Want%20You%20to%20Know.pdf https://loss.helplinecenter.org/suicide-loss-and-grief/ https://dr-kari.com/my-approach/common-humanity#:~:text=This%20idea%20of...

December 2023: Navigating Boundaries with Grace: Empowering Statements to Decline Conversations and Uphold Respect

As we go into the holiday season, you might be experiencing some anxiety, frustrations, or even unhappiness about being around certain people. These people might be the type that do not respect your boundaries, voice their opinions unwarranted, or even assume that you have the same beliefs/ideas/priorities as them. Although it can be very common to be engrained growing up that we have to be respectful and listen to others no matter what they talk about, this mentality can be very harmful, especially depending on the topic or things being said.  Establishing and maintaining healthy boundaries is an essential aspect of self-care and personal well-being. In our journey through life, we often find ourselves in situations where we need to decline conversations without compromising our own mental and emotional health. It's crucial to communicate our boundaries with respect and assertiveness, especially when certain topics or behaviors are not okay. In this blog, we'll explore a range...

July 2023: Making Conflict Work in Your Relationships

          Ever heard the saying that people in “good” relationships NEVER fight or argue? It seems like we have been taught this ridiculousness that arguing or conflict in relationships is the #1 red flag and we need to avoid them at all costs. Fortunately, this is not the reality of real, genuine relationships because disagreements and misunderstandings do arise even within good-intentioned partners. In fact, conflict can serve as a meaningful opportunity to develop and strengthen the bond in relationships.  Often these moments can be fueled by anxious, avoidvant, or disorganized attachment styles. A great way to begin to get ahead of conflict in relationships is to research and learn about what your individual attachment style is and how that relates to your partner’s attachment style. Typically, anxious-attached partners are attracted to avoidant-attached partners. However, it's super important to know that attachment styles are not set in stone! Th...